Every Mets rumor starts the same way. You’re half-asleep, scrolling your phone, and there it is. “Mets linked to…” “Mets interested in…” “Mets checked in on…”
Then your group chat lights up like a Christmas tree in Queens. One guy is already photoshopping the player in a Mets jersey. Another guy is screaming that Stearns is cheap. Someone posts “SOURCE???” like they are doing investigative journalism from a toilet.
Most of those rumors are not news. They are signals. Learn the signals, and you stop getting emotionally mugged.
This is your Mets Fan BS Detector. Seven tests. Fast reads. No wasted hope.
The one thing to remember
A rumor is not a report. A rumor is someone trying to make something happen, or trying to make you think something is happening.
The 7 types of Mets rumors
1) The agent leak
What it is: An agent whispering “the Mets are in” to raise the price.
Why it happens: The Mets have money, attention, and the media will repeat it.
What it sounds like: “Strong interest” with zero details.
BS level: High.
If it’s real: You will see real terms or a real timeline shortly after. If nothing follows, it was leverage.
2) The Mets leverage leak
What it is: The team using the media to move the market.
Why it happens: The Mets want a player cheaper, want a seller to blink, or want a different team to pay.
What it sounds like: “Mets prefer X type of player” right after talks stall.
BS level: Medium to high.
If it’s real: You see action. A meeting. A second reporter. A report of money discussed.
3) The opponent leverage leak
What it is: Another team leaks the Mets to pressure their target.
Why it happens: “Pay up or the Mets will.”
What it sounds like: A rumor appears in one place, then spreads fast, still with no terms.
BS level: Medium.
If it’s real: The Mets show up in more than one serious outlet, not just a copy-paste chain.
4) The courtesy call
What it is: “We checked in” means the Mets called and asked what the price is.
Why it happens: Teams do this all day. It means almost nothing.
What it sounds like: “Monitoring” “keeping tabs” “doing due diligence.”
BS level: Very high.
If it’s real: “Checked in” becomes “engaged” or “talks have advanced,” with names of the players involved.
5) Deadline inflation
What it is: July turns every reliever with a pulse into “a high-leverage piece.”
Why it happens: Sellers squeeze desperate teams.
What it sounds like: “Mets in on multiple bullpen arms.” No specifics.
BS level: Medium.
If it’s real: Prospect tiers start getting mentioned. Not names, tiers. “Top-10 type” or “upper-level starter” talk.
6) Aggregator telephone game
What it is: Someone paraphrases someone else, then the paraphrase becomes “reporting.”
Why it happens: Everyone wants clicks. Nobody wants accountability.
What it sounds like: “Reports say…” with no original source.
BS level: Extremely high.
If it’s real: You can trace it to one primary reporter who actually covers a team, not a quote farm.
7) Beat writer temperature check
What it is: The reporter is taking the vibe of the situation.
Why it happens: Front offices leak “temperature” to keep options open.
What it sounds like: “Feels like the Mets could…” “Do not be surprised if…”
BS level: Medium.
If it’s real: Another reputable reporter confirms, or the same writer upgrades the language from vibe to fact.
The 5-question quick test
Run these five questions before you believe anything.
1) Does the Mets roster actually need this player type?
A rumor about another corner outfielder means something different than a rumor about a starter.
Need drives truth.
2) Does the money fit, not just today, but later?
Contract AAV is not the whole story. The Mets still have:
- future arbitration raises
- long-term deals already on the books
- luxury tax thresholds that change decision-making
Steve Cohen has money. The front office still has rules.
3) Does the roster math fit?
This is where rumors go to die. If they add a player, someone loses a spot:
- 40-man roster squeeze
- options burn
- DFA risk
- minor league depth gets exposed
If you cannot name the corresponding move, the rumor is probably noise.
4) Who benefits from this rumor being public today?
Ask this every time. Every time!
Agent benefits.
Other team benefits.
Mets benefit.
Media benefits.
Someone is always getting paid in attention or dollars.
5) What would we see next if it’s real?
A real rumor leaves footprints.
You should see at least one of these:
- follow-up reporting from another legit outlet
- terms or structure discussion
- urgency, a deadline, a meeting
- a corresponding roster move hinted
If it’s real, this happens next
This is the checklist that separates “possible” from “happening.”
Real signs
- Two or more reputable reporters say the same thing independently
- Details appear: years, AAV range, prospect tier, medical check, timetable
- Counter-leaks show up: “Team X is in too” means there is a live market
- The Mets move comes into focus: trade candidate, DFA name, roster opening
Fake signs
- One outlet.
- One tweet.
- “Linked.”
- “Monitoring.”
- “Interest.”
Those words are the junk food of baseball news.
Common Mets fan traps
Trap 1: Confusing “connected” with “close”
Connected means someone said the Mets name out loud. Close means terms are being argued about.
Trap 2: Overvaluing prospects you have never watched
Fans fall in love with the idea of a prospect more than the player.
Prospects are valuable. They are also unfinished.
Trap 3: Thinking money means no constraints
Cohen’s wallet is not the same thing as smart roster construction.
A bad deal blocks three good ones later.
Trap 4: Believing in “one move fixes it”
Baseball does not work like that.
Teams win because of depth, not because of one headline.
The Mets Rumor Scoreboard
Use this like a cheat sheet.
Most likely to be real
- Beat writer temperature check that upgrades over time
- Deadline inflation with real prospect tiers mentioned
Middle
- Opponent leverage leak
- Mets leverage leak
Mostly noise
- Courtesy call
- Agent leak
- Aggregator telephone game
What you should do next
Bookmark this.
Next time a rumor hits your timeline, run the five-question test.
If it fails, ignore it and keep your blood pressure under control.
If it passes, then lean in.
That is the difference between being informed and being farmed for engagement.
Take a look at the Mets Top 25 Prospects for 2026
Mets Trade Ideas – How to get pitchers by giving up players from the infield.
Join the conversation at RandomMetsFans.com
Subscribe to the newsletter
Let’s build the smartest Mets community on the internet
Join the conversation at RandomMetsFans.com
Subscribe to the newsletter
Let’s build the smartest Mets community on the internet